By GhanaNewsPage 
A Closer Look at Controversies Surrounding Ghana’s Judiciary Head
In recent months, Ghana’s Chief Justice, Her Ladyship Justice Gertrude Araba Esaaba Torkornoo, has faced increasing public scrutiny over decisions and perceived actions that have sparked heated debate in the legal and political landscape.
Table of Contents
While her position demands neutrality and unwavering commitment to justice, critics argue that certain judgments and statements have cast a shadow over her impartiality and the judiciary’s independence.
Who is Chief Justice Gertrude Torkornoo?
Appointed in June 2023 as the 15th Chief Justice of the Republic of Ghana, Justice Torkornoo brought with her years of legal expertise and judicial experience. She is the third female Chief Justice in Ghana’s history and a respected legal scholar. However, her tenure so far has not been without controversies.
Also Read: WAEC Revokes Licences of 574 Schools Across West Africa Over Malpractice and Non-Compliance
The ‘Sins’ or Controversies Associated With Her Tenure
Below are some of the key criticisms and controversies that have generated public debate and raised questions about the judiciary’s image under her leadership:
1. Allegations of Judicial Bias in High-Profile Cases
One of the most prominent criticisms stems from the perception that the judiciary, under her leadership, leans toward government interests in politically sensitive cases. Several opposition parties and civil society organizations have questioned the neutrality of certain rulings, particularly those involving electoral disputes, anti-corruption cases, and political prosecutions.
Public Reaction: Many Ghanaians on social media and political commentators have cited her perceived “silence” on issues of selective justice as problematic.
2. Lack of Judicial Transparency and Accountability
Critics have also accused the Chief Justice of failing to push for greater transparency in judicial appointments and promotions. Concerns about favoritism and the politicization of the judiciary have resurfaced, with some legal practitioners calling for reforms in how judges are vetted and appointed.
Stakeholders Say: The Ghana Bar Association and some think tanks have urged the Chief Justice to take bold steps to address corruption allegations and ensure transparency in the legal process.
3. Controversial Comments on Wealth and Morality
Justice Torkornoo’s remarks during a judicial forum in 2024, where she reportedly stated that “judges deserve to live in comfort” and should not be judged for owning luxury assets, sparked public outrage. Critics viewed the comment as insensitive, especially at a time when the general public is struggling with economic hardship.
Public Sentiment: Many saw the statement as a disconnect between the judiciary and the people it serves.
4. Inadequate Reform in Justice Delivery System
Despite her promises to modernize and digitize Ghana’s court system, progress has been slow. Delays in court processes, outdated case tracking systems, and limited access to legal aid continue to affect justice delivery across the country.
The Asogli State Council has officially
Justice Delayed: For many citizens, the slow pace of justice remains a major concern, and critics argue that her tenure has yet to deliver on major reforms.
Balanced View: Supporters Speak Out
It’s worth noting that supporters of Chief Justice Torkornoo defend her integrity and achievements. They argue that her leadership has brought discipline to the bench and promoted legal literacy through judicial education programs. Her push for judicial automation and ethical enforcement within the judiciary is also praised by legal scholars.
Whether these issues are genuine failures or just growing pains of a modern judiciary remains to be seen. However, public perception is a critical part of judicial credibility, and Chief Justice Torkornoo’s ability to restore confidence in the system will be vital in defining her legacy.
As Ghana prepares for another election cycle, the spotlight on the judiciary will intensify. It remains to be seen how the Chief Justice and her team will navigate the complex political-legal landscape and safeguard the sanctity of Ghana’s democracy.
#Chief Justice #Gertrude Torkornoo
